The Milwaukee Brewers are poised for a transformation in their starting rotation as the offseason approaches. With key players like Frankie Montas and Colin Rea entering free agency, managerial decisions made now could redefine the team’s pitching identity for the upcoming season.
The Brewers’ front office made headlines recently when they confirmed Montas’ decision to decline his mutual option worth $20 million for the 2025 season. This decision leaves Milwaukee with a significant vacancy to fill in their rotation. Additionally, the organization opted against Rea’s $5.5 million club option, meaning both pitchers will be seeking new contracts elsewhere. Montas, who played a substantial role in the team’s efforts following his acquisition prior to the trade deadline, generated a mixed performance during his time in Milwaukee. His overall 4.84 ERA and a modest strikeout tally reflect inconsistency—qualities that often raise concerns among management.
Rea’s statistics paint a different picture as well. With a commendable 12-6 record and a 4.28 ERA, he showed promise but struggled in high-pressure moments, specifically during the final month of the season when he posted an 8.31 ERA. His omission from the NL Wild Card Series roster is a stark indicator that the coaching staff may have lost faith in his ability to deliver when it counts most.
The Brewers’ recent activity on the roster includes some significant player transactions. Right-hander Kevin Herget has been claimed off waivers by the New York Mets, while left-hander Rob Zastryzny heads to the Chicago Cubs. Meanwhile, first baseman Jake Bauers and right-hander Bryse Wilson cleared waivers, solidifying their demotion to Triple-A Nashville.
Herget’s performance in Milwaukee had been minimal but effective, highlighted by a 1.59 ERA in his brief stint. His departure may not create an immediate void, but it does emphasize the need for usable depth in the bullpen. Zastryzny, too, contributed positively with an impressive 1.17 ERA, but like many pitchers, consistency in performance is paramount for retention in the majors.
For Bauers and Wilson, their demotions might signal a need for reevaluation of their contributions to the team. Bauers finished the season with a lackluster batting average of .199, which contributes to the narrative that the Brewers are looking for offense upgrades. Wilson managed a respectable 4.04 ERA but will need to sharpen his skills to reclaim a regular spot on the roster.
As the Brewers look ahead, the focus will likely be on forming a reliable pitching rotation that can withstand the rigors of a long season while remaining competitive in a challenging division. The offloading of Montas and Rea opens avenues for fresh talent, be it through free agency or trade. Investing in youth and screening potential pitchers who may provide the consistency missing in past seasons could be the key to Milwaukee’s success.
Moreover, strengthening the lineup through trades or scouting promising hitters can create a more balanced team and complement the pitching staff effectively. The Brewers must act judiciously to turn the offseason into an opportunity for growth and refinement rather than a setback.
The Milwaukee Brewers are at a pivotal crossroads. With changes in their pitching staff on the horizon, the next steps taken during the offseason will be crucial in setting the stage for what could either be a resurgence or a missed opportunity in the upcoming season.
Leave a Reply